HISTORICAL STUDY: THE TEN KINGDOMS
Alamanni
p. 1 Gibbons Rome Chap 10 p 25-29. Chap 11 p 18-22. Chap 12 p 20. Chap p 12. Chap 19 p 20 ... 22-26. Chap 25 p 18-20. Chap 26 p 19-20. Chap 30 p 18, 19. Chap 36 p 5. Chap 38 p 5. Chap 49 p 21-22-iv. Zimmerman’s Hist of Germany Vol 1 p 183MMM 416.1
The Franks
Chap 10 p 22. Chap 12 p 18, 21, 22. Chap 19 p 20. See notes for Date 351. Chap 31 p 39. Chap 36 p 5. Chap 37 p 18. Chap 38 p 3-31MMM 416.2
Burgundians
Chap 10 p 8, 10. Chap 25 p 20. Chap 30 p 14, 17, 18. Chap 31 p 39.MMM 416.3
Vandals
Same as Burgundians 6 31 p 36. C 33 p 5, 6, 11, 12. In Spain 409. In Africa 429. 36:1-3, 4, 12-16, 20, 11. 41:1-14.MMM 416.4
Art. Summary on
p. 2 Suevi Britannia Goths Suevi occupied a part of the pennisula now known as Portugual.MMM 416.5
Territory of Burgundians Hallam’s Middle Ages Chap 1 p 1 See 9 Note 8 Whole valley of Saoneand Lower Rhone and w half of Switz to Med Sea
P. 3 Alamanni first and Empire North of the Main. 211-217.
The limit of Roman Empire, the Wall of Prains and Hadrian See Ginn and Heath’s Classical Atlas Map 8. 282-350. Al. took all from main to Lake of Constance. East of Rhine. 351. Constantius gave Al. and Fr all they would take west of Rhine and at that time the Al. were established in Alsace and Lorraine. C 19 p 20. 455. Al. and Fr advanced from Rhine to Seine.
496 Clovis defeated the Alamanni but they held Alsace and Lorraine see Chap 49 p 22-iv.
p. 4 The Wall in Britain Chap 1 p 5, 6. Just above Edinburg and Glaseam. Dambarton-Edinburg. Britain was a part of Roman Empire over 400 years.
Green’s Larger History of England. Chap 1.Knight’s History of England. Chap 4.
Suevi
p. 5 Chap 10 p 25. Ditto Burg. and Val.MMM 417.1
Chap 30 p 14-18. Chap 31 p 36, 38. Chap 33, p 5. Shows location of Suevi. Chap 35 p 4. Chap 36 p 7. LL.
Goths
10:3, 4, 8-13, 16-18, 21, 30-39. 11:10-17. C 14:34-36. (C 17:31, 32.)MMM 417.2
18:13, 14. C 25:31-33, Ost and Vis. 26:1, 13-19. The Separation.
The Visigoths
26:13-19. 21-24. 26, 29-33. 30:1-12, C 31:2, 14-31, 35, 37-40. 36:5-7, 22. 31:39. C 38:2 & 29. Date 419.MMM 417.3
Anglo-Saxons-449
31:41, 42. C 37:18. C 38:31-42.MMM 417.4
Ostrogoths
35:9-16. 36:12, 28, 34. 37:18. 38:2, 11, 12, 13, 15, 42. 39:2, 4-21. 41:16-32.MMM 417.5
p. 6 Blank
The Huns
p. 7 C 26:1-13. C 34:2-7, 9-15. C 35:1-16.MMM 417.6
Hungarians-Avars Not Huns. Physical History of Mankind by James Combes Prichard, MD. FRS MRIA, etc.
Vol. 4 p 320.
Empire of Huns disappears from history but is succeeded by that of the Bulgarians. Avars followed the Huns. After them the Chazors.
Machiavelli’s History of Florence. Chap 1 and C 2 p 1.
1. Visigoths, 2. Burgundians, 3. Franks, 4. Vandals, 5. Alans, 6. Huns, 7. Angli, 8. Heruli, 9. Ostrogoths, 10. Lombards, 11. Suevi, 12. Zepidi.
p. 8 Brittanica Huns. Almost immediately the kingdom dissolved. Some returned to Ural. Chambers Art Huns. Adams’ History Chart. Prichard’s Physical History of Mankind, v 4. C 16. See 6 p 1. Kaeppen’s History of Middle Ages. Alloe-----tiv 470.
Machiavelli’s History of Florence. Chap 1 p 6, 7. Thoughts p 472. Barne’s Note. Peopling of earth 259, 260.
Lombards 453
p. 9 10:8. 37:29. 42:2. 43:16, 17. 45:2-9, 14-18.MMM 418.1
Heruli
10:8. 25:31. 35:9. 36:28-34. 39:7, 8.MMM 418.2
Gepidae
10:8. 34:5. 35:9, 16. 36:12. 39:11. 42:2. 45:3, 4.MMM 418.3
Alani
12:11. 26:12, 13. 30:18. 31:36, 38.MMM 418.4
Search Wilbur’s Outlines of Unusual History See 183
p. 10 Britannica Odoacer
Odoacer interfered with the Bishop of Rome. Bower’s History of the Popes 463.
p. 11 Oakland June 26, 1888—Under the Law
Romans 6:14, 15: “Under the Law.” Under the condemnation of the Law “Hupa namas”
Romans 3:19. Different Greek expression. Should be “in the law.” “En ta namas.” See Boise’s Notes on Galatians and Romans.
1 Corinthians 9:20. Under the Law. “hupa namas.”
1 Corinthians 9:21. Under the Law. In the Law. “En namas.”
Galatians 4:21
Galatians 3:23
Galatians 4:4, 5
Galatians 5:18
1 Corinthians 9:21 and Romans 9:21
Acts 19:39 Lawful. “En namas”
p. 12 Newton on the Prophecies, p. 210. He gives five lists.
p. 13 Butler says “till” or “until” ever points to a limit
Daniel 1:21. Psalm 112:8. Isaiah 42:4. 1 Samuel 15:35.
p. 44. Other law given by Angels. An assertion only. Angels first mentioned in connection with the Law. Acts 7:53. “Disposition” set in order. Leviticus 26:46. Read the chap.
Numbers 4:37
p. 58. Galatians 4:4 “Made means Born.” The Greek “Geneta” here rendered Made in over 600 cases, but two or three times means Born.
p. 14 Blank
p. 15 SDA Positions on the Law
J.N.A. in Rev. Vol. 2, p. 29; J.N.A. in Rev. Vol. 3, p. 37; J.N.A. in Rev. Vol. 1. Hist. of Sab. p. 186 footnotes. Wesley’s Sermons, Vol. 1, p. 313. Walker’s Plan of Salvation, Chap. 15, p. 154 notes.
p. 16 Blank
p. 17 Meaning of Added in Galatians 3:19. “Added“: See Deuteronomy 5:22. “Spoken“: Hebrews 12:19. Both referring to Moral Law the same in original of Galatians 3:19. Two texts where this applies to the moral Law. No instance where it is applied to the Ceremonial. By means of Transgressions. Boise’s Notes on Galatians 3:19.
p. 18 Blank
WCW Notes, pp. 19, 21
p. 19MMM 419.1
| Scand. Life of C |
700 |
| Mission Pledges |
200 |
| For Brorsen |
100 |
| For Dan Ed |
100 |
| For Swedish Ed |
100 |
| For Ger and Fr |
200 |
| For-C-M |
$100 |
| For For. S |
$100 |
| For Salary |
$100 |
| For Poor C |
$100 |
| H Ed |
$200 |
p. 20 BlankMMM 419.2
p. 21MMM 419.3
1883 J.G.M. K.B.MMM 419.4
J.N.A. D.P.B. J.E.MMM 419.5
J.N.L. A.A.J. J.T.MMM 419.6
1888MMM 419.7
Scand. J.G.M. O.A.O. N.C. E.G.O. K.B. M.H. R.H. S.H.MMM 419.8
C. Europe. J.H.W. E.W.W. H.P.H. A.R. L.R.C. J.V. C.L. A.R.MMM 419.9
Notice. J.C. A.V. J.E.MMM 419.10
English. S.N.H. D.A.R. J.H.D. A.A.J. W.A. J.T. W.S. G.R.D. H.H. J.O. N. MeKe. S.A.W. Notice Smith. Mrs.S.MMM 419.11
Aust. G.C.T. M.C.I. Curtis. H.S. H.B. J.B. A.I.D. R.H. A.J.C. J.L.F. A.Le RueMMM 419.12
p. 22 BlankMMM 419.13
p. 23 Psalm 114:9MMM 420.1
Romans 11:29. Calling of God without repentance.MMM 420.2
The Gifts Ps.MMM 420.3
Psalm 116:12, 13. The Cup of SalvationMMM 420.4
Acts 17:24, 25. Giveth life and all thingsMMM 420.5
Acts 14:16, 17. Did good and gave fruitful seasonsMMM 420.6
Who given to Romans 3:10-18MMM 420.7
Matthew 5:44, 45. Love your enemies.MMM 420.8
Christ died for sinner. Romans 5:6-8, 10MMM 420.9
The Calling of Isaiah 45:22.MMM 420.10
p. 24 BlankMMM 420.11
p. 25 Zimmerman’s Hist. of German, Vol. 1, p. 183 Constantine worded in legal form in 308MMM 420.12
p. 26 BlankMMM 420.13
p. 27 10 a.m. Oct. 15, 1888. U. SmithMMM 420.14
When this question was proposed on Comm.MMM 420.15
Utterly unnecesssary. Tendency of evil. I stand on defensive. When we look over this past work & find the old paths. A Spirit comes of unrest. This view has stood the test 40 yrs. The new view should be tested as long. If we have diversity of testimony why change. Not Reform. But tearing up of old truth.MMM 420.16
Sit calmly by & see foundation stone taken out with ruthless hands Distinctions unnecessary. Are we to confine ourselves to one point Ten Kings imply indicated (??) the breaking into 10 parts & cannot accept the idea that after 2 (or 3?) fell there were but 7. God of sets up K with just ten.MMM 420.17
p. 28 BlankMMM 420.18
29—Revelation 17 shows 7 heads & 10 horns.MMM 420.19
Little horn was a spiritual power & these were subdued & opposition remained.MMM 420.20
The three soon disappeared.MMM 420.21
Ostragoths in Italy disappeared thus (?) is Italy one of the divisionMMM 420.22
Soundness in remarks of Scott (??)MMM 420.23
As to the particular point I am laboring at a disadvantage. Did not know it was coming up. Some seem to have understood it and brought in libraries.MMM 420.24
The ArticlesMMM 420.25
Rev. Vol. 64, nos. 1-4.MMM 420.26
Our enemies look to these nations which are the proximate cause of the downfall. Kaepeen’s Middle Ages, Vol. 1, chap. 5.MMM 420.27
p. 30 BlankMMM 420.28
p. 31 Appearance of Huns 375 the Signal for etc. Shepherd says about 358 Hist agree that here was the great impulse. Passage of Goths in 378. The Huns. One of these wild races that finally caused the Fall of Rome. Hunnic Domination caused Huns Mirgals etc.MMM 421.1
Shepherd 183. 190. 182, 183. Pannonia acceeded to Huns in 424.S v 3 p 16 & 386, 437, 451. Keeppan 1:93, 194. Dungessick to 970. The Huns being the first to strike of Pannonia, must be those to give their name to the territory.MMM 421.2
Shepherd’s Fall of Rome 211, 218. Ephumeral Empire. Shephard 288. The aprations of the Avars about 560 and 570. Since the middle of 4C on the lower valleys of Danube a perpetual succession of Hunnish tribesMMM 421.3
p. 32 still perpetuate the traditions of Attilla. Preface of M. Terry to his book.MMM 421.4
Gibbon vol 3 p 387 last note. Why not read it allMMM 421.5
Story of Hungary byMMM 421.6
Shepherd’s History of Rome. Correction of the----of Gibbon.MMM 421.7
p. 33 Machiavelli names the 10 and among them the Huns. Does he name more?MMM 421.8
by same reason can strike out three others of the list.MMM 421.9
p. 34 BlankMMM 421.10
p. 35 THE LAW AND THE GOSPEL. EJW. OCT. 15, 1888MMM 421.11
Luke 2:10, 11MMM 421.12
Luke 2:10, 11MMM 421.13
1 Timothy 1:1MMM 421.14
Romans 2:13: The Angels are doers of the Law. Satan accuses them and they can appeal to the law.MMM 421.15
R. C. church shows itself antichrist in pointing men to pilgrimage, penance, etc.MMM 421.16
Did Christ speak the Law.MMM 421.17
G. C. Vol. 2, p. 216.MMM 421.18
We believe in Divinity of Christ. He is God. He Created all things in Heaven & in the Earth.MMM 421.19
1 Corinthians 10:9. Israelites tempted ChristMMM 421.20
John 5:21 The Same Hour.MMM 421.21
God has revealed himself through Christ.MMM 421.22
The justice of God.MMM 421.23
Ill. A King offers himself to suffer the penalty of disobedience & redeems the condemned.MMM 421.24
p. 36 BlankMMM 421.25
p. 37—If God’s Acts are always in Harmony with His Law. (am sorry for the If) is it not necessary for him to keep the Sabbath. How can he keep the fifth Com.MMM 421.26
God is not a subject of law. But as it proceeded from Him, all his acts will be in harmony with it.MMM 421.27
It is implied that God enacted part of His Law, & then added to it.MMM 421.28
That is as men do, who fmeet (??) new contingencies. Gods law provides for all creatures, & all time.MMM 421.29
The 10 Com. are the Rule of Heaven & Earth.MMM 421.30
The LessonMMM 421.31
Romans 10:4. He who comes to Christ for Righteousness admits that the law demands R.MMM 421.32
I am the Way truth & Life. Christ justifies us, by giving us his Life.MMM 421.33
Romans 1:16, 21MMM 421.34
p. 38. The Law is the highest place. When man deviates from it, he is beneath it, under it.MMM 422.1
p. 39. Justification by Faith. Our Anchor. A Key to Unlock.MMM 422.2
Romans 3:28.MMM 422.3
James 2:17, 22.MMM 422.4
Do we work to gain the favor of God or for justification. No. But to show our Love to God.MMM 422.5
Romans 6:18. Galatians 5:18. Romans 8:6. Romans 8:1. Romans 3:19. Gr. in the Law.MMM 422.6
1 Corinthians 9:19-22. v. 21. Gr. In the Law.MMM 422.7
Without Law. Romans 2:12. Acts 14:15. 17:(??)MMM 422.8
Is it proper to say Adam Fell. The Angels who kept not their first Estate Fell. Risen with Christ Lest any Fall afterMMM 422.9
p. 40 BlankMMM 422.10
p. 41 THE TEN KINGDOMSMMM 422.11
1. Why we came prepared with LibrariesMMM 422.12
2. Established positions torn up by Ruthless Hands. Here are Facts. In 1884 Eld W wrote from Gen Conf for me to get out Historical Articles.MMM 422.13
My Letter to Smith & His Letter.MMM 422.14
... (References and discussion of 10 kingdoms) ...MMM 422.15
Chap 14:19. 33:2, 4, 34;2, 424.Chap 33:3. Chap 1:27. The Illgrian Frontier included pannamiaMMM 422.16
When the Huns were in W R neither the Lombards, the Heruli and the Visigoths were with the Huns and had not established any kingdom in the Empire. Brittanica. Art Alamanni Chap 49:22.MMM 422.17
p. 42 BlankMMM 422.18
p. 43 Clavis did not extinguishMMM 422.19
Chap 19:24. 38:5. Chap 26:19. Chap 38:10 Burgundians were as much extinguished as the Alamanni. Did Machianelli ennumerate the ten kings.MMM 422.20
He says Chap 1:6, 7; 2:1, 10.MMM 422.21
Nimton gives five lists and Leyman’s chart gives 1.MMM 422.22
Papacy came up amongst ten. Three plucked up by the roots. Papacy wears three crowns and represents the three kingdoms that were plucked up. Must find 10 at the first or they could not be referred to as 10.MMM 422.23
There are just seven there now.MMM 422.24
p. 44 BlankMMM 422.25
p. 45 THE TEN KINGDOMS—U. SmithMMM 422.26
Had no misgiving as to the position. Glad to have List brought out.MMM 422.27
Glad he has done it.MMM 422.28
The Flexibility of the Prophecies. Not for us to contract & expand the Scriptures.MMM 422.29
The prophecies must define this.MMM 422.30
2 Chronicles 7:19MMM 422.31
2 Kings 17:23MMM 422.32
We do not fear to take positions because the general intelligence of the people is suchMMM 422.33
[even pages blank from here on]MMM 423.1
P. 47 THE LAW AND THE GOSPEL John 8:32MMM 423.2
Under does not mean condemned.MMM 423.3
Under the Law no Under GraceMMM 423.4
Under the Law, is Condemned by lawMMM 423.5
In the Law, is primarily subject to the LawMMM 423.6
How are we related to the Law.MMM 423.7
Outside of Christ, & In ChristMMM 423.8
Romans 1-6 a compact argument. In the rest of the Chap. it is amplified. Augustine says It is one thing to be in the Law, and another to be Under the Law. He who is In the Law acts according to Law. He who is Under the Law is acted upon according to Law.MMM 423.9
John 8:33-35 Jews were slavesMMM 423.10
Romans 7:19, 20. The experience of those who struggle with condemnatiorMMM 423.11
Verse 21 is not Christians experience.MMM 423.12
Proverbs 5:22 2 Peter 2:19 11(??)MMM 423.13
Hebrews 2:14, 15 Romans 8:17-21MMM 423.14
Psalm 68:6; 102:19, 20MMM 423.15
Pet (sic) Spirits in PrisonMMM 423.16
49—Luke 4:18-20MMM 423.17
Paul was in prison. Manacles on his hands. All his attempts to serve God are useless and vain, until he receives deliverance through Christ. 4 p.m.MMM 423.18
Romans 7:1-6 Romans 6:20, 21; 5:6.MMM 423.19
Fruit of 1st husband shows like he was. James 1:17, 18. Our own sinful nature. Our own carnal desires.MMM 423.20
We see Paul so alive to his condition of bondage, almost in despair. Next verse shows freedom in Christ.MMM 423.21
We are in love with our carnal natures. God wants us to hate it. The law shows the degradation of the union. Christ wants us to be united to Him. He proposes a union with himself. That which is real life would be union(??). In the figure the union is unlawful and the end is death.MMM 423.22
Ill. Gangrene in the Hand, the Arm, the whole Body. A Hopeless disease of the Blood. Isaiah 1:4-6.MMM 423.23
51—Mark 7:21, 22MMM 423.24
We do not accept the first offer of 2nd husband because when the old man dies, we die too.MMM 423.25
The Old man dies at 2nd death. The Wages of Sin is death, without exception. In Chap. 6.1—The Law Oct. 19, 1888MMM 423.26
Acts 15:28, 29. To abstain from polutions of Idols in a way covers all the 10 Com. Sabbath with the rest as Sun worship was the essence of Idolatry.MMM 423.27
We have taught that the typical law was done away. Did the Apostles fasten on them things done away years before.MMM 424.1
Galatians 2:11-21 v. 19 Cer L nailed to the cross. Did it Kill Paul.MMM 424.2
If R by the Law, If favor could be obtained by good works penance, etc(??) Christ need not have died.MMM 424.3
53—Galatians 3:17. Compare the Covenant with Abraham with the Second Covenant. They are the same.MMM 424.4
I am dependent on Christ to lead me.MMM 424.5
Can be led to the place of G.R.MMM 424.6
Ill. Cultured man & uncultured wife.MMM 424.7
Romans 3:21.MMM 424.8
Hebrews 7:19; 9:10. Galatians 5:11.MMM 424.9
55—SmithMMM 424.10
Scripture uses justified by the Law. Under the Law, & Dead to the Law are used in two senses.MMM 424.11
Romans has no reference to Galatians.MMM 424.12
Felt importance. Danger of position.MMM 424.13
KilgoreMMM 424.14
I opposed bringing up the question, especially when it was said that Dr. W was misrepresented. I considered it an unfortunate matter to come up here. If W had been sick I would have opposed its coming up.MMM 424.15
It is cowardly.MMM 424.16
There has never been an opportunity as Dr. W. has had.MMM 424.17
Another thing has troubled me. The experience of 16 yrs. ago. Report “A Test. to Eld. Waggoner.MMM 424.18
57—If that was not the matter I want to know it.MMM 424.19
SmithMMM 424.20
Was speaking on the issue. 3/4 of what Bro. W. presents I fully agree to. I admired Eld. W’s articles 16 years ago.MMM 424.21
MorrisonMMM 424.22
I regret that I cannot come before a congregation without being nervous. We all need God’s blessing. I am imperfect & my imperfections will be manifest.MMM 424.23
Mingled feelings. Glad to defend the Truth. Sorry for the necessity of investigating this subject.MMM 424.24
I have investigated too freely. I opposed this coming up because no one is present who has given this subject special study.MMM 424.25
This question does not rest onMMM 424.26
59—eloquence. That cannot be put on paper.MMM 425.1
But few things said about the Moral Law, but what we agree to 2 Peter 3:16. Pauls hard to be understood. As in this epistle we find his reproof of Peter. It may be this that is hard to be understood.MMM 425.2
Positions on truth will be in lineMMM 425.3
2 Thessalonians 1:1, 2 Galatians 1:1-5MMM 425.4
1 Timothy 1:1, 2 Titus 1:1-4MMM 425.5
Pauls Salutations. A likeness.MMM 425.6
Does he state object of letter in the salutation.MMM 425.7
The Law in Galatians. Is it trusting in keeping a Law that is right to keep, or is it trusting in a law that it is not right to keep. v. 6 Christ called them. v. 7 not another, because it is a development of the former.MMM 425.8
61—A perverted gospel.MMM 425.9
Christ led them from one Gospel to another, which is not another. The Second reads “that called you by the grace of Christ” R.V. “that called you in”MMM 425.10
My position. The object of reproof no ordinary sin. Treason to Christ Stealing is not so bad as Treason.MMM 425.11
Galatians 1:6; 2:2; 3:1; 4:9-11; 5:7-11;MMM 425.12
It was a special sin. To make it an ordinary sin it does violation to B or G. Ex Mark of Beast Sin.MMM 425.13
v. 7 a perverted gospel.MMM 425.14
All agree that Acts 15 relates to same rulesMMM 425.15
What made counsel necessary. v 24MMM 425.16
Same Troubled you(??) Keep the Law. & Keeping of Law. Not trusting in it. Would Keeping of a right law subvert any. v. 5. What Law. that of Moses. v. 6. Consider this matter.MMM 425.17
63—to be uncircumcised, & keep the Law of Moses. What sub (??) in Galatians The Law of Moses.MMM 425.18
How discriminate bet L of G & L of MMMM 425.19
By distinctive TitlesMMM 425.20
James 2:8. Royal Law. Whole Law.MMM 425.21
Deuteronomy 5: Just 10 Com.MMM 425.22
Galatians 5:3. Another whole law of which circumcision is a part. Two Whole Laws. Nehemiah 9:13, 14. Com. Precepts Statutes & Laws, by the hand of Moses. 1 Kings 21:8. Law that I commanded & that Moses commanded them. should be 2 Kings 21:8 Second DayMMM 425.23
The Same Gospel IllustratedMMM 425.24
Ephes 3:3-5MMM 425.25
Acts 15:24. Keeping of the LawMMM 425.26
The GalatiansMMM 425.27
Sketches of Paul p. 192, 193 & 188MMM 425.28
The sub.. Keeping the Cer Law.MMM 425.29
p. 188, 189, & 192. Justification by a Round of Ceremonies.MMM 425.30
65—Acts 15:6. Apostles considered this matterMMM 426.1
A Review of Stakes!!! (sic) (??)MMM 426.2
Galatians 2:11-15MMM 426.3
I am a sinner by disobeying the Ceremonial Law.MMM 426.4
What law violated by working on the day of AtonementMMM 426.5
A man could not violate any part of the Ceremonial law without disobedience to moral law because it had a moral element in it. When the Cer Law was done away, was a moral element abolished. A Primary LawMMM 426.6
A Secondary Law.MMM 426.7
1st Relates to mans duty to God & manMMM 426.8
2nd Grows out of the existence of sin.MMM 426.9
v. 19. Romans 7: Through body(??) of lifeMMM 426.10
Contrast. (??) Through the Law.MMM 426.11
p. 67 Chap. 3 Paul’s argument. Ephes.MMM 426.12
Pi promise by Cov. and Cov. by promiseMMM 426.13
Yoke of ‘Bondage, The Cer. Law.MMM 426.14
Acts 15: Many yokes in the Bible.MMM 426.15
Jer. Bear the Yoke in his Youth.MMM 426.16
v.MMM 426.17
Sketches of Paul, p. 68 FridayMMM 426.18
Same points may be or may not be correct.MMM 426.19
Galatians 1:6 him, may refer to Christ to God or to Paul. It does not effect the argument. If it was no gospel at all it would have been correct for the apostle to so state it.MMM 426.20
Like of Paul 189MMM 426.21
69—Was it sin to transgress the ceremonial law. If God should say “climb a pole” ought I to do it. Yes.MMM 426.22
Did not sin bring in a new law.MMM 426.23
If Adam preached the Law & not the Gospel, would it not be sin.MMM 426.24
The moral element in a ceremonial law endures after the cer law passes away.MMM 426.25
A contract about my farm,, not bring into existence the farm & when the contract dies, the farm stays.MMM 426.26
The Rev. of StakesMMM 426.27
1. The Subject—The Law of Moses.MMM 426.28
2. SP p. 193. Was it JbF or the LawMMM 426.29
3. Reproof to Peter.MMM 426.30
4. Chap. 3:1 What mean, Yoke of bondage & the Liberty. The Yoke was not the law of 10 Com. but cer. percepts.MMM 426.31
Liberty—MMM 426.32
Not fair to go to other parts of Bible(??)MMM 426.33
and finding use of a word, bring itMMM 426.34
71—here, and say it must mean the same thing.MMM 426.35
Hebrews 13:23MMM 426.36
Acts 23: Paul given liberty & it sometimes means privilege.MMM 426.37
Galatians 2:4.MMM 426.38
1 Corinthians 8:9-13MMM 426.39
1 Corinthians 9:20-22MMM 426.40
Romans 3:19. Under the Law, means not in harmony with the law.MMM 426.41
(condemned by the Law)MMM 426.42
73—Dead to the Law by a change of relationship.MMM 427.1
Romans 6:3; 3:9.MMM 427.2
by comfortable under the Law, but if under sin a sting(??)MMM 427.3
Ill. The Blanket. Romans 6:14MMM 427.4
1 Corinthians 15:56.MMM 427.5
Romans 7: Does not the sinner have to make some advancement before Christ will accept him.MMM 427.6
Romans 7:11, 12. v. 13.MMM 427.7
John 6:44. Man must pass up through the 7th Chap. of Rev. before the marriage takes place.MMM 427.8
Popular Doctrine says Two leaps carry a man from sin to perfection.MMM 427.9
75—Ephes. 2:1-3MMM 427.10
Galatians 3:1—Seek those things that are above. A place not so easily reached.MMM 427.11
2 Peter 2:8MMM 427.12
Philippians 3:12MMM 427.13
1 Peter 5:10MMM 427.14
1 believe in a certain kind of perfection. Perfect submission to the Will of God.MMM 427.15
77—TuesdayMMM 427.16
After Faith is come, we are no longer under the Schoolmaster. What this Faith.MMM 427.17
The Seed. When the seed came we are no longer under the Schoolmaster.MMM 427.18
Chap. 4.MMM 427.19
Under the elements of the World refers to backsliding.MMM 427.20
2 Corinthians 3:6-11. The Cer. Law?? (sic)MMM 427.21
The Moral Law introduced at Chap. 5:14. Eld. Smith SpeaksMMM 427.22
I have no hesitation in expressing my views. I had no time to pass over this with him.MMM 427.23
There is no material difference between us on the law spoken of in the Epistle to the Galatians.MMM 427.24
79—We cannot appreciate the feelings of the Jews, etc.MMM 427.25
Acts 13:38. Jews expected justification through the Law of Moses. It was regarded not as a means, but as an end.MMM 427.26
Some think because moral law is referred to, that it all relates toMMM 427.27
M. L. (moral law—b. h.)MMM 427.28
The Relation bet ML the CL and Christ, when Paul preachedMMM 427.29
Acts 15:13 It is said that conclusion relates to M.L.MMM 427.30
v. 20. After removing the restraint of C.L. Continued on points most in danger.MMM 427.31
Galatians 2:14. Not sinners of the Gentiles. He keeps up this distinction. I through the Law, am dead to the Law. Never dead to 10 com. in this sense.MMM 427.32
81—Ill. The two husbands. Never dead to the Law in that sense as the 2nd husband is united the same instant as death of the first.MMM 428.1
Galatians 3:18, 19MMM 428.2
One family could easily be kept separate. The Nation of Millions required this law to keep them sep.MMM 428.3
In beginning God gave a law that could give life.MMM 428.4
Chap. 4 The Two Laws.MMM 428.5
Ishmael learn(??) according to nature.MMM 428.6
When Isaac grew Ishmael was cast out.MMM 428.7
I Rejoice in S of P F(??) because of its harmony, easy to be understood.MMM 428.8
A man holding the other view met a Campbellite, and had to resort to this position.MMM 428.9
83—The Schoolmaster. We have allusion to the light of new dispensation.MMM 428.10
[CD-ROM Editor’s Note: On pp. 429-470 are published actual copy of the W. C. White handwritten note pages from Book One (“E”) just transcribed on pp. 415-428.]
NOTES MADE BY W. C. WHITE
AT THE MINNEAPOLIS MEETINGS, 1888
A Photocopy of the Original Follows This Typescript Copy
Book Two (“AA”)MMM 471.1
p. 1 EWF [Farnsworth] 7:30 p.m. Oct. 12, 1888MMM 472.1
Parable of Importunate Widow and Unjust JudgeMMM 472.2
When Christ comes shall He find faith on the earth?MMM 472.3
Are we not in a time of indifference? There is an influence that follows prosperity, peace and plenty that is harder to meet than persecution.MMM 472.4
Matthew 24:11-13. False prophets shall arise. The love of many shall wax cold. Will iniquity outside cool our love? Is it iniquity among us?MMM 472.5
This Gospel must be preached in all the world, and then shall the end come. Only one thing that can separate us from God and that is sin. Our people came up to C.M. to get warmed up, to get the blessing of God. Then they go home and cool off. Is it not a law with metals that every time they are heated and then cool, they grow harder?MMM 472.6
Experience at the C.M.’s. LW Lost Love, Iniquity abounds.MMM 472.7
p. 2 During the (two?) years 13 or 14 members have left us. They have not only left the truth but some have gone into iniquity and nastiness too horrible to be told.MMM 472.8
In the last days perilous times shall come etc.MMM 472.9
Held C.M. where 20 brethren drove 313 miles to the meeting. How would you feel to hold C.M. when in a radius of 50 miles there are 1,000 or 1,500 Sabbathkeepers and only 300 attend?MMM 472.10
Some are in darkness because of broken vows. Having a fear of Godliness but denying the power thereof. True of us. Is there not power in God’s grace to overcome pride, ambition, jealousy, and other sins. From such turn away.MMM 472.11
p. 3 What can bring about a different state of things? Any talent we neglect to use, we lose. So of the grace of God. We should bring before all the relation that a converted man should sustain to God. His whole life should be devoted to God. The Tract So[ciety] Camp where two-thirds ministers time when straightening out church trials. If all would work devotedly there would be less trials. Missionary element leaking out of our Tract Societies.MMM 472.12
p. 4 Minneapolis. Oct. 13, 1888. E. G. White 1 John 3:1-9. Behold what manner of love the Father hath, etc.MMM 472.13
Sunday, Oct. 14, 1888, 9 a.m. E. J. W[aggoner] Matthew 23:8-12. In the church is no authority but Christ.MMM 472.14
p. 4 1 Peter 2:25 Christ the Bishop.MMM 473.1
John 21 Words to Peter.MMM 473.2
John 10:11 The Good ShepherdMMM 473.3
Hebrews 13:20 Shepherd and Bishop the sameMMM 473.4
Titus 1:5, 7 Elder & Bishop=SameMMM 473.5
1 Peter 5:1-4 Elders, feed the flock. Who feeds the flock? The ShepherdMMM 473.6
John 10:2-5 The true shepherd goes before the flock and leads them. Peter says not as lords but to be ensamples to the flock. A man may preside without leading a meeting.MMM 473.7
1 Timothy 3:1 A good workMMM 473.8
Acts 20:28 Elders called overseers. David as shepherd slew the bear.MMM 473.9
Ezekiel 33:1-6 Elder a Watchman.MMM 473.10
Ezekiel 3:17 Made thee a watchman. See sheep jumped out of the fold.MMM 473.11
p. 5 2 Corinthians 1:3-5, 6; Hebrews 5:1-2; Isaiah 10:11 (gathers the lambs); Isaiah 42:1; Luke 4:18 Elders duty to heal the broken hearted, etc. 2 Timothy 2:24 (apt to teach, patient)MMM 473.12
Sunday, 4:00 p.m. R. A. U. [R. A. Underwood]MMM 473.13
Matthew 18:15-17. How to deal with the erring.MMM 473.14
p. 6 Philippians 2:2, 3; Romans 12:10; 1 Corinthians 5:9-11; Jude 1:22, 23; Psalm 87:4, 5, 6; Mark 13:34; Work is the remedy for church trials 2 Peter 1:8; Hebrews 13:17, also 7; Numbers 16; Numbers 16:3-5, 11.MMM 473.15
p. 7 1:30 p. m. Oct. 14, 1888. L. R. Conradi. Matthew 24:14MMM 473.16
Among 300,000,000, 700 believers, one to a half million.MMM 473.17
The US a large country, but Russia is larger, 8,000 miles across. Population 104 million. U.S. 9 M Keil. Russia 23 M K Russia at large as full as U.S. 5 to 8 miles Eu R 23 to sq mi. 112 different nations each has dialect 1/14 part of the world.MMM 473.18
Baltic Prov. only ever came in contact with the Ref Ger Mis in 1186. Luther felt special interest in R and sent ministers to Russia. Free cities of R united in the protest. Baltic Prov. became Lutheran. The Bal Greek Catholic.MMM 473.19
In Russia more picture and images than in Italy or elsewhere. In Moscow 700,000 people 400 (?) churches. They believe they are saved by their works and not by faith.MMM 473.20
Years ago R was liberal. Germans went to escape the army. In 1776MMM 473.21
p. 8 25,000 Germans started at once and crossed to Seratam. All through R little bodies of Protestants. At first liberal, they made the Lutherans free and equal with the Greek church.MMM 473.22
Change in laws first of this century, 1,000 laws they have about religion.MMM 473.23
p. 8 The R church allows the Bible and has a Bible Society. They sell it with the apocrypha. The Eng So must sell it in parts.MMM 474.1
The members of the GCC can never leave it. The children of mixed marriages must be educated in Greek faith. One trying to separate one from church he may be banished. If he hinders one intending to join GC he loses property and rights.MMM 474.2
p. 9 The Greek church only can receive members of another. Lately 100,000 ignorant ones were induced to join GC by the promise of lands, and when they found their condition they could not change. Baptists the only Americans working in R 16 or 17,000 Ger Bap in R.MMM 474.3
They take their Bibles, and show what it teaches. One taught, baptized, and fled. Count scattered tracts and was given choice of Eng or Liberia. He went to LondonMMM 474.4
The Pres Eurp. feels his only safety in the church. He went to Kein and made great promises. Then the church demanded that those who proselytze be sent to the mines. Many Russians have embraced Protestantism. 4,000,000 Protestants in Russia.MMM 474.5
How did belief of Advent get to Russia? Many believe the Lord is coming. Bengel preached his coming in 1836.MMM 474.6
p. 10 His disciples taught it in Russia. The Mennonites came to US and learned Present Truth. They sent back publications and we found Sabbathkeepers and among them a Russian. A minister cannot enter R. Newspapers are examined by a censor. His story.MMM 474.7
We have 40 or 50 in Crimea. The Elder went to the and there there are 70-75 S-K now 80 on the Volga nearMMM 474.8
In L. a R church of members. A Baptist working on the Volga was banished to In Poland 60 to sq. miles. Some Polanders got some tracts on Who Changed the Sab of a bro.MMM 474.9
p. 11 He showed it to another and gave the address. He got tracts and went from Poland to Crimea to be baptized. First Rus. Tract 250 Ger Russians SK. One has just gone to R through Basel.MMM 474.10
Evangelical Alliance in 1887 prepared an address in Aug asking for more liberty. The head of church in Jan 1888 answered that the Greek Church was the barrier against the heathen of Asia and they cannot allow their members to be taken from them.MMM 474.11
p. 12 J. F. Hansen, C. C. Lewis, Lewis Johnson, A. O. Tait, Swift, Haskell, L. T. Nicola, D. T. Shireman, George B. Starr, W. B. White, M. M. Olsen, A. D. Olsen, Fred Jensen, S. S. Shrock.MMM 474.12
p. 13 Committees for Conf.MMM 474.13
Nom: J. Forga, J. B. Goodrich, D. T. JonesMMM 474.14
Resolutions: R. A. Underwood, A. T. Robinson, L. R. Conradi, E. J. Waggoner, E. H. GatesMMM 474.15
Credentials: R. M. Kilgore, I. D. Van Horn, H. NicolaMMM 474.16
p. 13 Finance: H. Lindsey, A. R. Henry, C. H. Jones, C. Eldridge, A. T. Jones, and all conf. presidentsMMM 475.1
Dist. of E. W. Farnsworth, [S. H. Lane crossed out], Lewis Johnson, Labor: G. G. Rupert, [L. R. Conradi crossed out], A. J. Breed, C. H. Jones, and Gen. Conf. Comm.MMM 475.2
Auditing: J. Fargo, A. R. Henry, [D. T. Jones crossed out], H. W. Miller, C. Eldridge, J. W. Raymond, A. T. Robinson, andMMM 475.3
p. 14 Gen Conf. CommitteeMMM 475.4
Programme: R. M. Kilgore, R. A. Underwood, J. B. GoodrichMMM 475.5
Spec. Com. W. C. White, D. T. Jones, A. T. Robinson on Cred:MMM 475.6
p. 15 Monday Eve, October 15, 1888, L. R. Conradi; Germany and HamburgMMM 475.7
17 canvassers in Germany. In Schwiz the R in one Canton is $14 per mo. P work in Russia. He came to Schwiz and there book menMMM 475.8
told him it would not sell. But he did sell. In Germany it was hard to start. Hamburg a free imperial city for 600 years. It has practically a monopoly of some lines of trade. 70,000 emmigrants came through Hamburg.MMM 475.9
p. 16 Sentinels : 5,000 Michigan; 5,000 Minnesota; 4,000 New York City, 4,000 Iowa; 4,000 Kansas; 4000; 3,000 Wisconsin; 3,000MMM 475.10
O. C. Godsmark, D. T. Bourdeau, F. E. Belden, A. Jones, W. H. Edwards, J. F. Hansen, D. E. Lindsey, C. W. Olds.MMM 475.11
p. 17 Arkansas-226+60; Min. J P Henderson; Lic. 1 in field, 2 canvassing Australia 266-335; Tithe in 10 m $35,000. G. C. Tenney, S. McCulloch, Echo Pub House, M. C. Israel, W. D. Curtiss, Foster, Bell; $3,900 raised for A Pub Association, A Mission Training School, A SS Association, A Tract SocietyMMM 475.12
p. 18 C. P. Haskell, W. B. White, N. P. Nelson, G. B. Starr, Wm Covert, Vic Thompson, B. F. Purdham, R. B. Craig, C. A. Washburn, H. R. Johnson, W. H. Wakeham, W. R. Smith, L. T. Nicola, J. W. Bagby, L. J. Rousseau, C. McReynolds, S. S. Schrock, C. A. Hall, C. W. Flaiz, J. N. Brant, H. S. Lay, F. D. Starr, H. W. Miller, M. B. Miller, W. OstranderMMM 475.13
P. 19 Writers on LessonsMMM 475.14
1. Call of Moses- S. N. HaskellMMM 475.15
2. Resisting the TruthMMM 475.16
a. Moses a God to Pharoah and AaronMMM 475.17
b. The plagues vs idolatryMMM 475.18
3. Resisting the TruthMMM 475.19
Healing by MediumsMMM 475.20
4. God’s care for His peopleMMM 475.21
p. 20 A. D. Olsen, L. Johnson, H. Grant, A. Moon, F. L. Mead, C. C. Lewis, J. W. Watt, J. P. Gardner, W. C. Boynton, VI. N. Hyatt, E. E. Miles, M. H. Brown, M. C. Wilcox, T. H. Starbuck, J. E. Swift, H. M. Mitchell, J. M. Rees, H. W. Decker, T. T. Stevenson, F. H. Purdham, R. D. Hottel, W. J. Stone, W. W. Sharp, W. S. Hyatt, B. M. Shull, P. H. Cady, T. H. GibbsMMM 476.1
p. 21 Conf. No. 2. 1888 Our Committee Report adopted without change. Missionary Ship Committee asked to report.MMM 476.2
S. H. Lane-The Southern FieldMMM 476.3
Not a hard field compared with the Old Country. A good canvassing field. Better than N.E. Good for vol. 4 Marvel and Thoughts.MMM 476.4
Some take 35 orders a week. They are hospitable and will furnish lodgings to an agent if he is sociable.MMM 476.5
The color line is there. It has come to stay. If you try to shove it into the Gulf it will shove you north of Ohio. Reiner speaks of colored brothers as brothers. Get the whites to point out the responsible blacks.MMM 476.6
J. M. Reese spoke for North Carolina. A pretty good field. The people are stable. Do not move nor give up the Truth. 1 man since cotton picking time has served orders for 600 Marvel, 300 helps to Bible students.MMM 476.7
p. 22 S. N. Haskell, L. R. Conradi, A. T. Jones, E. W. Farnsworth.MMM 476.8
p. 23 Committee on Finance and Christmas Offerings: W. C. White, C. H. Jones, R. A. Underwood, E. W. Farnsworth, A. T. JonesMMM 476.9
To Write Readings: S. N. Haskell, L. R. Conradi, A. T. Jones, E. J. Waggoner, J. G. Matteson.MMM 476.10
To Publish and Mail: W. C. Sisley, H. W. Kellogg, Mrs. W. H. Edwards.MMM 476.11
To Suggest Christmas Entertainments: F. E. Belden, Mrs. J. F. Waggoner, C. C. Lewis.MMM 476.12
p. 24 Kindergarten Work; SS and the Home; Our Present NeedMMM 476.13
p. 25 SS Association No. 1MMM 476.14
Reports growth of work. The mission fields; Pitcairn and the ship, etc.MMM 476.15
Important Matters:MMM 476.16
1. Officers who travelMMM 476.17
2. Lessons. Ready for 1889; What for 1890; European Lessons; Lessons for children.MMM 476.18
3. The SS WorkerMMM 476.19
4. The SS ManualMMM 476.20
5. Childrens C. M. MeetingsMMM 476.21
6. The ContributionsMMM 476.22
p. 25 Nom: Kilgore, Robinson, BreedMMM 477.1
Res: Waggoner, C. C. Lewis, [A. O. Tait crossed out], M. B. Miller, W. W. Sharp, M. C. Wilcox.MMM 477.2
Audit: F. E. Belden, M. H. Brown, A. D. Olsen [Jerome Fargo and J. B. Goodrich crossed out]MMM 477.3
p. 26 L. C. Chadwick, R. A. Underwood, A. J. Breed, [E. H. Gates crossed out], S. H. Lane, Dan T. Jones, Wm Convert, H. W. Decker, C. H. Jones, C. Eldridge, G. B. StarrMMM 477.4
p. 27 International Tract Society, Oct. 19, 1888MMM 477.5
The objects of the Society: Our Home Field and New York. Foreign Fields calling for attention.MMM 477.6
The Congo (?)MMM 477.7
Report of the years workings of the Society for the year.MMM 477.8
p. 28 Mother’s experience at MedfordMMM 477.9
p. 29 Sabbath p.m. October 20, 1888, E. G. White; 2 Peter 1:11-(?)MMM 477.10
God gave Satan a chance to develop himself. When Christ came Satan had taken possession of the Jews. Christ preached deliverance Luke 4:18, 19. At first they assented. Afterward they began to doubt. All heaven is open toMMM 477.11
When you have the Holy Spirit, you have everything. He gave His son. He could not give. This little world is chosen.MMM 477.12
When Christ was crucified Satan was uprooted from the affections of the universe. John 12:22.MMM 477.13
p. 30 J. S. Gibbs, G. H. Rogers, W. B. Hill, W. W. Sharpe, M. G. HuffmanMMM 477.14
p. 31 Gardner-Nebraska needs an old minister and a Scandinavian. Indianapolis, Ind needs a minister. Stephensen-Texas wants Kilgore Gibbs- British Honduras wants a canvasser, names J. Q Reynolds of N.O. La. Houses united in Sept. Wants to work north. G. H. Rogers-Illinois supposed he had strong lungs till he went to Ill. Seaboard south of ohio.MMM 477.15
Starbuck-N.P. Says S. Fulton is not strong. Has gone to St. Helena, Cal. Says John asks a release. Decker-UC-Johnson was sent to Montana for the summer. Would prefer to return to Nebraska, but would move to Montana if recommended.MMM 477.16
p. 32 Covert-Indiana-Wants a laborer to help a few weeks. Wilcox, NY, the only ministers are Brown, Place and Robinson.MMM 477.17
Starr-Chicago; Lane-Key. Needs everything.MMM 477.18
p. 33 F. M. Secretary’s ReportMMM 477.19
New Books a Necessity. (1) Book on the Prophecies (2) New Ed. Dan and Rev. (3) GC vol. four (4) Holland Books (5) Polish, Finnish, Armenian, Russian, Chinese, Indian, Spanish, Portuguese, Greek, Hawaiian, and native tongues.MMM 477.20
The Increase of CapitalMMM 477.21
Australia; Africa 6,000; England 10,000; Scandinavia 2,000; Central Europe 10,000MMM 477.22
p. 33 EducationalMMM 478.1
Olson’s Letter; Aust and So Africa; Central Europe; School of Int. Secretaries; Canvassers schoolsMMM 478.2
Economy to EducateMMM 478.3
Why and HowMMM 478.4
Ex Swiss LaborersMMM 478.5
p. 34 WCW, LRC. ATR, GSR, C. Eld, I. D. Van Horn, W. Ost[rander], G. B. Starr Conradi, Bourdeau, Eldridge, Schrock, HansenMMM 478.6
p. 35 Expense of Mission Offices: Their influence to educate office workers in the fieldMMM 478.7
BC College ComsMMM 478.8
Nom: H. W. Miller, A. J. Breed, R. A. UnderwoodMMM 478.9
Res: A. T. Robinson, W. W. Prescott, T. H. StarbuckMMM 478.10
p. 36 R&H MeetingMMM 478.11
Book Sales 98,000; Books on hand 64,000; Loss on Journals 4,204.42’ Gain on Inst. and Rev. 2,300,00=1,904.42; C. M. TeachantMMM 478.12
p. 37 1. His feelings naturalMMM 478.13
2. Michigan feelings naturalMMM 478.14
3. The separation of twinsMMM 478.15
4. Our apparitions last yearMMM 478.16
5. A visit to missionsMMM 478.17
6. Pres or memberMMM 478.18
7. Farnsworth’s speech HealthMMM 478.19
8. Health and other businessMMM 478.20
9. The two argumentsMMM 478.21
10. The bug and the applesMMM 478.22
1. Mich Del motivesMMM 478.23
2. The health reportMMM 478.24
3. The StoryMMM 478.25
p. 38 Reared a Sabbathkeeper; married and husband went to army; a severe sickness and wonderful experience; raised up several children; experience with false brethren; my burden because of unconsecration; Moved to Mankat (?) 1885.MMM 478.26
Brother Mead prejudiced by EWF; Bro Quinn a Christian; visited and harshly treated by Elder Farnsworth; then neglected at quarterly meeting I attended to hear record; appealed to Iowa Conf Comm; wishes to know if she was properly disfellowshipped. Mrs. H. K. Farnham, No 2934 7 1/2 ave Minneapolis. H. Nicola, H. Grant, J. H. Morrison.MMM 478.27
p. 39 Revision of Thoughts. Matteson write to Comm.MMM 478.28
History of Sabbath. Wait for Historical referencesMMM 478.29
Prophecices of Jesus. (?)under way.MMM 478.30
GC Vol 4: Revise to chapter 19; consider abbrev 6 chaptersMMM 478.31
Life of Christ: Propose to modify assertions. Will write to committee.MMM 478.32
Improve illustrations.MMM 478.33
The New Earth: Swedish. Is it not a good one to put into the FinnishMMM 478.34
[CD-ROM Editor’s Note: On pp. 479-504 are published actual copy of the W. C. White handwritten note pages from Book Two (“AA”) just transcribed on pp. 471-478.]